OPINION | What Annoys Me the Most About Casting Directors? Ambiguity! 

By Carmichael Phillip

  • OPINION 

    What Annoys Me the Most About Casting Directors? Ambiguity! 

    I want specifics! I’m trying to book this thing.

    (The Anonymous Actor)

    (Photo: Pixabay | Pexels)

    You know what annoys me the most about casting directors? Ambiguity. The lack of clear and specific direction!

    I’m sure I’m not the only actor who has been left scratching their heads after a casting director tells you what they want you to do, except the instructions sound like they’re speaking in a foreign language.

  • Let me give you a few examples:

    “Go bigger this time.”

    “Pick up the pace.”

    “Just have fun with it.”

    “Do it again, but with more feeling.”

    “Switch it up a little this time.”

    “Try doing it with more energy.”

    Huh!?!? Like, seriously. Can anyone decode these messages for me?

  • You go in to an audition, nervous AF! You don’t want to admit it, of course. But this is a big opportunity. You really want to book this role. You’ve learned your lines and prepped your tail off.

    You do a pretty good job on the first read. Then, the casting director decides to redirect you.

    That’s when the whole thing usually goes off the rails. Because, if you’re going to adjust my audition, I want specifics.


    It’s a big audition! I want to know exactly what the casting director wants from me, so I can deliver.


    It’s a big audition! I want to know exactly what the casting director wants from me, so I can deliver. I want them to be as specific as a GPS giving me directions as I drive through a bad neighborhood.

    I want to hear the equivalent of, “Turn left on LeBrea, turn right on Santa Monica Blvd.”

    It’s just so frustrating when the casting director, instead, gives me the equivalent of, “Go to the end of the street and do something fun.”

    Huh?!?! I want specifics! I’m trying to book this thing!

  • Having cast a few small roles for some short films myself, I understand the problem. Casting directors see a lot of actors during the process. They can’t always give detailed instructions to each actor. It would take way too much time.

    So, casting directors end up speaking in shorthand. Specific directions get distilled into vague suggestions in the interest of time.

    Plus, CDs want to see your interpretation of the role. So, rather than hold your hand every step of the way, they would rather give you a vague suggestion and let you run with it.

    Still, it’s a pet peeve of mine. I’ve had many moments of confusion, as I’ve tried to decode what a casting director was asking me to do. I’ve also lost many potential roles that way.

    “Do it with more energy this time,” says the casting director.

    I will, as soon as I figure out what the hell that means.


  • You Might Also Like:
    What are Residuals?


     

    Recommended Posts

  • Ad

  • Who is the actor in the sleep Company ad? (Anil Kapoor)

    Who is the actor in the sleep Company ad?  The legendary “Evergreen” superstar brings his ageless energy to the SmartGRID revolution in 2025. (By Carmichael Phillip) The Sleep Company | SmartGRID Ad featuring…

    What Actor Turned Down the Most Money?

    What Actor Turned Down the Most Money? Exploring Legendary Stories of Actors Who Walked Away from Huge Paydays (By Javier Guerra) (Matt Damon in Ford v Ferrari) Turning Down Millions: A Rare Hollywood…

    Who is the Least Known Actor?

    Who is the Least Known Actor? Exploring Unsung Talents and Hidden Gems in the Film Industry (By Javier Guerra) Defining What It Means to Be “Least Known” When we think of actors, our…

    Who is the Hardest Actor to Work With in Hollywood?

    Who is the Hardest Actor to Work With in Hollywood? A Look at Industry Perspectives and Notorious On-Set Challenges (By Javier Guerra) (Photo: Ahmet Yalcinkaya/Unsplash) Understanding the Myth and Reality of “Difficult” Actors…

    How Did Ice Cube Get Into Acting

    How Did Ice Cube Get Into Acting From Gangsta Rap Pioneer to Hollywood Powerhouse: The Unlikely Evolution of Ice Cube’s Career (By Carmichael Phillip) A South Central Beginning: Music as the First Act…

  • Ad

  • What age did Scarlett Johansson start acting?

    What age did Scarlett Johansson start acting? From childhood auditions to global stardom—how Scarlett Johansson’s early start shaped her career (By Carmichael Phillip) A Budding Star: Scarlett’s Passion Ignites Early Scarlett Johansson’s journey…

    Why did Scarlett Johansson almost quit acting?

    Why did Scarlett Johansson almost quit acting? The surprising reasons behind the Marvel star’s doubts about Hollywood and how she overcame them (By Carmichael Phillip) Early Stardom and the Pressure to Perform Scarlett…

    How John Travolta Got Into Acting

    How John Travolta Got Into Acting From New Jersey dreamer to Hollywood icon—how John Travolta found his path to stardom (By Carmichael Phillip) A Childhood Surrounded by Showbiz John Travolta didn’t stumble into…

  • Ad

  • How Mark Hamill Got Into Acting

    How Mark Hamill Got Into Acting The journey of a small-town actor who became a pop culture icon. (By Carmichael Phillip) (Mark Hamill in Star Wars) Early Life and the Spark of Acting…

    What method of acting does Timothée Chalamet use?

    What method of acting does Timothée Chalamet use? Exploring the techniques and emotional depth behind one of Hollywood’s most compelling young actors (By Carmichael Phillip) A Modern Actor with Classic Sensibilities Timothée Chalamet…

    How Jason Alexander Got Into Acting

    How Jason Alexander Got into Acting An exploration of the early life and career of the beloved actor (By Carmichael Phillip) (Jason Alexander) Early Life and Inspirations Jason Alexander, best known for his…

    How Ben Stiller Got Into Acting

    How Ben Stiller Got Into Acting A Journey Through Comedy, Family Legacy, and Personal Dedication (By Carmichael Phillip) Early Life and Family Influence Ben Stiller, one of Hollywood’s most versatile and well-loved actors,…

    How Bill Murray Got Into Acting

    How Bill Murray Got Into Acting (By Carmichael Phillip) Bill Murray, a legendary actor known for his offbeat humor and captivating performances, has become an iconic figure in both comedy and drama. From…

  • Ad

  • How Denzel Washington Got Started in Acting

    How Denzel Washington Got Started in Acting A look at his journey in showbusiness (By Carmichael Phillips) (Denzel Washington in Fences) RELATED TOPICS: Actor Profile: Denzel Washington How Denzel Washington Got Started in…

    Three Different Scenes for a Self-Tape! 

    Three Different Scenes for a Self-Tape! Is that asking for too much? (By Javier Guerra) (Photo: Andrea Piacquadio | Pexels) An actor friend of mine received a breakdown for an audition recently. The…

    ACTOR STORY | “Just Show Up!” 

    ACTOR STORY “Just Show Up!” How Terry Crews became a famous actor, simply by making himself available (By Carmichael Phillips) “If you just show up, a lot of times your opportunities are there.”…

  • Ad

  • OPINION | Same-Day Auditions Feel Disrespectful 

    OPINION  Same-Day Auditions Feel Disrespectful  Don’t they understand that we all have lives?  (The Anonymous Actor) (Photo: Andrea Piacquadio | Pexels) Now, don’t get me wrong. I’m certainly grateful for each and every…

    ACTOR STORY | “It’s About Nothing!” 

    ACTOR STORY “It’s About Nothing!” How Jason Alexander landed the role of George Costanza on ‘Seinfeld’ (By Tonya Tannenbaum) (Jason Alexander) Jason Alexander once had a self-tape that he thought was going to…

    ACTOR STORY | Mark Ruffalo was Hiding in Plain Sight 

    ACTOR STORY Mark Ruffalo was Hiding in Plain Sight How Hollywood finally discovered Mark Ruffalo (By Carmichael Phillips) (Mark Ruffalo in Zodiac) When casting directors saw Mark Ruffalo perform, they couldn’t believe how good…

    Did Method Acting Break Will Smith? 

    Did Method Acting Break Will Smith? Perhaps Will Smith was still in character during the infamous “slap”… (By Carmichael Phillips) What caused Will Smith’s now infamous slap at the Oscars? What made him jump…

    ACTOR STORY | A Casting Director Hunted Me Down for a Self-Tape 

    ACTOR STORY  A Casting Director Hunted Me Down for a Self-Tape  (The Anonymous Actor) (Photo: Andrea Piacquadio | Pexels) I got in trouble with my agent for not submitting my self-tape recently. A…

  • Ad