Casting Directors Discuss How They Select Talent
An inside look at the audition process, decision-making, and what truly sets actors apart
(By Carmichael Phillip)
(Photo: Rebrand Cities | Pexels)
The Art and Psychology Behind Casting Choices
Casting directors are the invisible architects of film and television. While directors and producers often receive most of the spotlight, casting directors shape the emotional tone and believability of a story through their choices. According to veteran casting director Sarah Finn, known for her work on the Marvel Cinematic Universe, “Casting isn’t just about who looks the part. It’s about finding the actor who feels the part — someone who naturally brings truth and depth to the character.”
Casting decisions often come down to an intangible element: energy. Finn explains that chemistry reads, subtle eye contact, and emotional authenticity weigh far more heavily than an actor’s resume. The most successful auditions are those where an actor stops performing and starts being. “You can feel when someone fits,” she says. “It’s like a puzzle piece snapping into place.”
Casting directors also pay attention to how actors interact with others in the room. Collaboration, humility, and adaptability can elevate a good audition into a great one. “Sometimes, it’s not about who delivers the best line,” says David Rubin, Academy Award-winning casting director. “It’s about who listens best.”
What Happens in a Casting Session
Behind closed doors, casting sessions are equal parts creativity and logistics. A director’s vision, a producer’s demands, and the realities of scheduling all converge in these crucial moments. The first round usually involves taped or live auditions. Actors are given “sides” — short scenes from the script — to perform.
Casting associate Megan Lewis describes the process as “a collaboration between instinct and experience.” She adds, “We might see 200 actors for a single role. You develop a sense for who has something unique — an angle you hadn’t thought of.”
Callbacks often narrow the field down to a handful of contenders. Chemistry reads follow — especially for romantic or ensemble roles — where the director evaluates how different actors connect. “Sometimes you have two amazing people, but only one combination feels right,” says Allison Jones, the casting director behind The Office and Superbad.
Even at this stage, nothing is guaranteed. Notes from producers, agents, and even network executives can influence the final call. The best casting directors, however, remain advocates for their choices. They fight for the actor who embodies the essence of the role, even when the industry pressures lean elsewhere.
The Importance of Authenticity and Preparation
One of the biggest misconceptions about casting is that it’s purely subjective. While chemistry and personality are factors, preparation and authenticity are what truly impress casting professionals. “We can always tell when someone hasn’t done their homework,” says April Webster, who cast Star Trek and Lost. “The actor who understands the script’s subtext, the tone, and the world of the character instantly stands out.”
Authenticity goes beyond memorizing lines — it’s about interpretation. The best auditions often surprise casting teams because an actor brings a new, unexpected truth to the role. Mary Vernieu, who cast Knives Out and Silver Linings Playbook, recalls a moment when an actor ignored a stage direction and instead improvised a reaction that completely redefined the scene. “That’s when I knew,” she says. “That’s our person.”
Actors who remain grounded and confident, without arrogance, tend to leave a lasting impression. Casting directors often jot notes like “believable,” “present,” or “truthful.” Rarely do they write “perfect.” The goal isn’t perfection — it’s presence.
Diversity and Representation in Modern Casting
The casting landscape has evolved dramatically over the past decade. Representation and inclusion are now central conversations in every major production. Casting directors are not only matching talent to roles but also shaping what Hollywood looks like on screen.
“Authentic casting matters,” says Carmen Cuba, the casting director for Stranger Things. “We’re not just filling quotas — we’re trying to make the stories we tell reflect the world we live in.” This includes greater representation of race, gender, sexuality, and ability.
The movement toward inclusive casting has also brought new opportunities for lesser-known actors. “When the door opens for more voices,” says Aisha Coley, who cast Selma and 13th, “we discover talent we might never have seen otherwise.”
Even when faced with studio pushback or traditional expectations, many casting directors have become champions for change. Their choices can alter public perception, shape industry standards, and redefine what audiences expect from storytelling.
The Role of Technology and Self-Tapes
Technology has revolutionized the casting process. Self-tapes and virtual auditions have made it easier for actors worldwide to be seen by casting teams in Los Angeles, New York, or London. However, with this accessibility comes new challenges.
“Self-taping has democratized the process,” says Alexa L. Fogel, the Emmy-winning casting director for The Wire and Ozark. “But it also means there’s more competition than ever. You have to make your tape feel alive.”
A good self-tape doesn’t rely on expensive lighting or cameras — it relies on truth. Directors and casting teams can see through over-rehearsed performances. “We’re looking for something spontaneous, something human,” Fogel adds.
Many casting directors now hold live callbacks over Zoom or other virtual platforms. It saves production costs and allows international talent to audition remotely. But despite the technology, one thing remains unchanged: the need for a genuine connection. “It’s still about the feeling in the room — even if the room is virtual,” says Bernard Telsey, known for Hamilton and Rent.
How Directors and Producers Collaborate with Casting Teams
Casting directors rarely work in isolation. The process is highly collaborative, involving producers, directors, writers, and sometimes studio executives. A casting director’s role is to interpret creative notes and present a curated list of potential fits.
Debra Zane, who worked on The Hunger Games, explains: “We’re translators. The director might describe a character as ‘wounded but resilient.’ Our job is to find the actor who embodies that.” Sometimes, the best choice isn’t obvious — it might be someone unexpected or unconventional.
Producers often have financial or marketing considerations, while directors prioritize artistic alignment. The best casting directors bridge both worlds, advocating for talent that elevates the story without compromising commercial appeal.
Zane notes that the process is not about control but trust. “When a director trusts the casting team, that’s when the magic happens. You start taking creative risks, and that’s where discoveries are made.”
Advice from Top Casting Directors for Aspiring Actors
When asked what advice they would give to aspiring actors, nearly every casting director emphasizes the same points: preparation, professionalism, and persistence.
“Don’t try to guess what we want,” says Avy Kaufman, whose credits include Life of Pi and Lincoln. “Show us who you are through the character. That’s what we remember.”
Jennifer Euston, known for Orange Is the New Black, adds, “Be kind to everyone you meet. Assistants today are casting directors tomorrow.”
Actors are also encouraged to keep learning — taking classes, exploring stage work, or producing their own projects. “The more you work, the more you discover your voice,” Kaufman explains. “That voice is what we’re all trying to find.”
The final piece of advice is patience. Careers in acting rarely happen overnight. The casting process can feel opaque, but each audition builds a relationship. “We might not cast you this time,” says Carmen Cuba, “but if you’re good, we’ll remember you. Always.”
Casting as a Craft of Connection
At its heart, casting is about connection — between actor and character, character and story, story and audience. Casting directors are the quiet curators of emotion, bridging vision and reality through instinct, artistry, and heart.
Their job goes far beyond selecting faces from headshots. They discover voices, shape narratives, and give life to words on a page. As Sarah Finn puts it, “When we cast well, the audience forgets it’s casting. They just believe.”
Acting Magazine Newsletters
Never miss out on the best from Acting Magazine.