How to Ace a Callback Audition?
Mastering the second round: tips, tricks, and real actor experiences to win the role
(By Jim Webb)
(Photo: Cottonbro | Pexels)
Understanding the Importance of a Callback
A callback audition is a second chance to make a first impression—even stronger. It means the casting team saw potential in your initial audition and now wants to explore more. Callbacks aren’t guarantees of a role, but they are a strong indication that you’re being seriously considered.
Casting director Marci Liroff once explained, “A callback means they’re taking a longer look at you. It’s your chance to show range, flexibility, and consistency.”
Unlike a general audition where casting directors are often seeing dozens or even hundreds of hopefuls, a callback is a more focused session. If you’re called back, you’ve already narrowed the field.
Come Prepared, Not Just Memorized
Being off-book is essential, but a callback requires deeper preparation than just memorization. Now’s the time to dive into:
Character motivation
Scene dynamics
Script nuances
Relationships between characters
Actor Florence Pugh noted, “For callbacks, I try to find something fresh about the character—even if I’ve already read the sides five times. There’s always a detail you missed.”
Research the production if you haven’t already. Know the tone of the show or film. Is it grounded? Comedic? Stylized? Bring your performance into alignment with the project’s world.
Be Consistent—But Ready to Adapt
If you got a callback, it’s likely because of something specific you did in your first audition. While it’s good to maintain that quality, you should also be flexible and take direction well.
Casting professionals often test your adaptability. They might ask you to perform a line differently, try a new emotion, or experiment with blocking. They’re not looking for perfection—they want to see how you handle change.
“Direction is the callback’s heartbeat,” said actor David Harbour (Stranger Things). “If you can shift gears without losing control, they know you’ll be reliable on set.”
Listen More Than You Talk
While most people associate auditions with performance, callbacks are also a place to demonstrate your ability to listen. This applies both in scene work and when receiving notes from casting directors or producers.
Being a good listener helps you:
Respond organically to your scene partner
Take direction without defensiveness
Show emotional intelligence on and off the script
Actor Andrew Garfield once said, “The most valuable thing I learned early on was to really listen—not wait for my line. That made my auditions, especially callbacks, way more alive.”
Be Aware of Chemistry Reads
Some callbacks involve chemistry reads—auditions with other actors to test your on-screen or on-stage connection. In these cases, casting is not just about talent but about energy, interaction, and timing.
Be open
Make eye contact
React genuinely to your partner’s choices
Casting director Jennifer Euston (Orange Is the New Black) explains, “A great actor might not get the part if they don’t connect with the lead. Chemistry can make or break a pairing.”
For example, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint had several chemistry reads before finalizing their roles in Harry Potter. “We had to find a balance between awkwardness and charm,” said Grint. “Callbacks let us explore that.”
Dress the Part—But Don’t Overdo It
Your outfit at a callback should be suggestive of the character without being a full costume. Wear clothing that supports the role’s vibe—tough, soft, casual, business—but avoid theatrical extremes unless specifically asked.
A hint of character is better than a full outfit
Keep it comfortable and clean
Make sure it doesn’t distract from your face or performance
“I wore jeans and a hoodie to my callback because the character was a laid-back teen,” said actor Dylan Minnette (13 Reasons Why). “It helped me feel grounded and in character without going overboard.”
Ask Smart Questions If Given the Chance
Sometimes casting directors offer a chance for actors to ask questions during callbacks. Use this opportunity wisely.
You might ask about:
The character’s backstory
The tone of the show or scene
Adjustments they’d like to see
But keep it short and relevant. You’re showing interest and professionalism, not stalling or second-guessing your preparation.
Director Greta Gerwig has said, “The best actors I’ve cast asked small, insightful questions during callbacks. It told me they were invested in the character, not just the gig.”
Know That the Room Might Feel Different
Callback rooms often include more people: directors, producers, sometimes even network execs. The tone may feel more intense.
Stay calm. This shift is normal and part of the process.
You might notice:
More focused silence
Fewer smiles
Less immediate feedback
Don’t let it shake you. These professionals are trained to observe, not necessarily react. Actress Rachel Brosnahan (The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel) shared, “My callback felt like a vacuum. No one laughed, and I thought I bombed. But a week later, I booked it.”
Rejection After a Callback Isn’t Failure
Even if you don’t book the role, a callback still means you made an impression. It’s part of a long game in building industry relationships.
Casting directors keep lists of memorable performers. A great callback—even if it doesn’t lead to a booking—might get you called in again.
Actor Riz Ahmed said, “I lost more parts than I got—but after a good callback, they remembered me. One day it was my turn.”
So walk out of the room with pride. You’ve already succeeded by standing out.
Keep Training Between Auditions
What separates actors who thrive in callbacks from those who falter? Often, it’s continued training. Voice, movement, improvisation, scene study—all contribute to deeper, richer performances.
Staying sharp means you:
Take direction better
Adjust with ease
Add layers to your performance
“It’s like an athlete training between games,” says coach Anthony Meindl. “Auditioning is your game day. You’ve got to keep your acting muscles strong.”
Final Thoughts: Confidence, Craft, and Consistency
The key to acing a callback audition is bringing a balance of confidence, preparation, humility, and professionalism. You’ve already made a strong first impression—now it’s time to build on it.
To recap:
Know your material intimately
Be adaptable and directable
Dress appropriately for the character
Listen well and engage genuinely
Handle pressure with grace
Actor Mahershala Ali put it best: “A callback is a handshake. You’ve been invited back to the room. Now shake hands with the role—and own it.”
Acting Magazine Newsletters
Never miss out on the best from Acting Magazine.