Game of Thrones: A Review

Game of Thrones: A Review

A deep dive into the epic highs and divisive lows of HBO’s fantasy phenomenon

(By Carmichael Phillip)

When Game of Thrones first premiered on HBO in April 2011, few could have predicted the cultural juggernaut it would become. Adapted from George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series, the show opened with a chilling supernatural threat north of the Wall before quickly shifting focus to the political drama engulfing Westeros.

What immediately set Game of Thrones apart was its brutal realism and refusal to follow conventional storytelling tropes. Characters who seemed to be central to the narrative were often killed off with shocking abruptness. As showrunner David Benioff said, “We wanted to make a show where actions had consequences and the stakes were always real.”

Season 1 laid the groundwork for this approach, culminating in the beheading of the presumed hero, Eddard Stark (Sean Bean). It was a daring move that sent a clear message: no one was safe. This narrative audacity catapulted Game of Thrones into must-watch territory.

One of the show’s most lauded qualities was its character development. Rarely were individuals wholly good or evil. Jaime Lannister (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau), introduced as an incestuous villain, evolved into a complex antihero. Similarly, Tyrion Lannister (Peter Dinklage), the outcast dwarf, became the moral compass of the story for many fans.

Peter Dinklage’s portrayal of Tyrion earned him four Emmy Awards and was a consistent highlight throughout all eight seasons. As Tyrion quips in Season 1, “I drink and I know things,” the line became iconic, encapsulating his intelligence and wit.

Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke) also stood out, initially portrayed as a powerless pawn who rose to become a formidable queen. Her journey from abused sister to liberator was as inspiring as it was tragic. Clarke described her character’s transformation: “Daenerys was always a mix of justice and fire. But in the end, it was fire that defined her.”

From the beginning, Game of Thrones pushed the boundaries of what was possible on television. Massive battles, exotic locations, and complex CGI creatures like dragons and direwolves set a new standard for production value.

The Battle of the Bastards (Season 6, Episode 9) is widely regarded as one of the most stunning battle sequences ever seen on the small screen. Director Miguel Sapochnik captured the chaos and claustrophobia of medieval combat with visceral intensity. “We wanted the audience to feel like they were in the mud and blood with Jon Snow,” Sapochnik said.

The show’s score, composed by Ramin Djawadi, was another key element of its atmosphere. The haunting “Light of the Seven” piano piece from the Season 6 finale is especially memorable, setting the tone for Cersei Lannister’s devastating act of vengeance.

Despite its successes, Game of Thrones was not without criticism. Many fans and critics expressed concerns about the depiction of sexual violence in the early seasons. Scenes such as Sansa Stark’s (Sophie Turner) wedding night in Season 5 sparked outrage, with critics accusing the show of using rape as a plot device.

In response, the showrunners eventually toned down these depictions. Actress Sophie Turner later said, “I felt a duty to portray Sansa’s resilience, but I was also relieved when her story shifted to empowerment instead of victimhood.”

Another point of contention was the show’s increasing departure from George R.R. Martin’s source material. By Season 6, the show had surpassed the books, and with that came a noticeable change in storytelling tone. Some fans argued that the show began favoring spectacle over character-driven drama.

Season 8, the final chapter in the saga, aired in 2019 and divided fans more sharply than any previous installment. The season was shortened to six episodes, which many felt was insufficient to resolve years of intricate storytelling.

The most controversial moment came in Episode 5, “The Bells,” when Daenerys, long seen as a champion of the oppressed, suddenly incinerated the innocent population of King’s Landing. While some argued this turn had been foreshadowed, others felt it was rushed and unearned.

Showrunner D.B. Weiss defended the decision: “The seeds of her madness were always there. She chose fear over love.” Still, fans launched petitions demanding a remake of the final season, which garnered over a million signatures.

Bran Stark (Isaac Hempstead Wright) being crowned king in the final episode also struck many as anticlimactic. Even actor Conleth Hill, who played Varys, said, “I felt frustrated. I felt like I had been thrown under the bus.”

Despite the controversies, there is no denying Game of Thrones’ cultural significance. The show redefined what television could be, creating watercooler moments week after week. From Halloween costumes to baby names like Arya and Khaleesi, the show left an indelible mark on pop culture.

It also inspired a wave of fantasy content on both the big and small screens. Shows like The Witcher, The Wheel of Time, and House of the Dragon owe much to the path Game of Thrones carved.

Critic Alan Sepinwall summed it up best: “Game of Thrones was lightning in a bottle. Even if the ending didn’t satisfy everyone, it changed the game.”

The acting across the board was stellar, with many cast members rising to global fame through their roles. Lena Headey (Cersei Lannister) brought icy calculation to her role, while Kit Harington (Jon Snow) portrayed a brooding hero torn between honor and love.

One of the show’s most famous quotes comes from Arya Stark (Maisie Williams), who, when asked what to say to the God of Death, replies: “Not today.” It became a rallying cry for fans and a testament to her character’s grit.

Charles Dance as Tywin Lannister brought gravitas and menace to every scene he was in. His quote, “A lion does not concern himself with the opinion of sheep,” became symbolic of House Lannister’s ruthless philosophy.

Game of Thrones was not perfect. It stumbled in its final act, and its ambition sometimes outpaced its execution. But for nearly a decade, it delivered some of the most gripping, emotional, and visually arresting storytelling ever seen on television.

Its impact will be studied and debated for years to come, and while the final season left a bitter taste for some, the journey to that point remains an epic worth remembering.

As George R.R. Martin himself noted, “I want my readers, and the viewers of the show, to be unsure what’s going to happen next. That’s what makes the ride worthwhile.”

Game of Thrones did just that — it made us feel, question, cheer, and despair. In doing so, it became a defining piece of 21st-century television.

Acting Magazine Newsletters

Never miss out on the best from Acting Magazine.

Sign me up for the newsletter!