The Two Gentlemen of Verona: A Review

The Two Gentlemen of Verona: A Review

William Shakespeare’s The Two Gentlemen of Verona is one of his early comedies, written in the late 16th century. Although not as widely recognized as some of his other comedies, such as A Midsummer Night’s Dream or Much Ado About Nothing, The Two Gentlemen of Verona offers a fascinating exploration of friendship, love, betrayal, and the complexities of human nature. With its intricate plot, memorable characters, and witty dialogue, this play remains a significant piece in Shakespeare’s body of work.

The plot centers around two young men, Valentine and Proteus, whose friendship is tested by love, misunderstandings, and the pursuit of romantic ideals. It is a play that delves into the dynamics of loyalty, self-discovery, and personal growth. Through its characters, The Two Gentlemen of Verona highlights the value of sincerity and the consequences of deceit. This review will explore the plot, themes, characters, and famous lines from the play, offering a deeper understanding of its enduring appeal.

The Plot

The plot of The Two Gentlemen of Verona revolves around the contrasting characters of Valentine and Proteus, two noble young men from Verona, who experience the complexities of love and friendship.

The play begins with Valentine leaving Verona to seek his fortune in Milan, while Proteus, his close friend, remains behind in Verona. Proteus is deeply in love with Julia, a lady of Verona, but when he is sent to Milan on a diplomatic mission, he falls in love with Silvia, the daughter of the Duke of Milan. His sudden change of heart causes a rift between him and his former lover Julia, who, disguised as a boy named Sebastian, follows him to Milan.

Valentine, who is in love with Silvia, becomes entangled in a series of romantic misadventures as Proteus betrays him and seeks to win Silvia’s affection for himself. The plot becomes a whirlwind of misunderstandings, mistaken identities, and acts of betrayal. Ultimately, after a series of confrontations and reconciliations, Proteus realizes the error of his ways, and through a series of fortuitous events, Valentine and Silvia are united, while Proteus is forgiven for his treachery. The play ends with a celebration of love, friendship, and redemption.

Key Themes

1. Friendship and Loyalty: The theme of friendship and loyalty is central to The Two Gentlemen of Verona. The relationship between Valentine and Proteus starts as a symbol of deep friendship. However, Proteus’ betrayal of Valentine over love reveals the fragility of their bond and the complexity of human emotions. Proteus’ shift from loyalty to betrayal challenges the idea of steadfast friendship and explores the idea of self-interest over camaraderie. This theme is powerfully expressed in the following famous line from Proteus, who speaks of his conflict between love and loyalty:

   “I’ll woo your lady, if I can’t win her, I’ll lay a wager that she is not won at all.” (Act 5, Scene 4)

   This line highlights Proteus’ willingness to betray his friend in pursuit of his own desires, a central conflict in the play.

2. Love and Betrayal: At its core, The Two Gentlemen of Verona is a comedy about love, but it also grapples with the darker side of love—betrayal. Proteus’ quick shift of affection from Julia to Silvia and his willingness to deceive Valentine for the sake of his new love shows how love can lead to moral compromise. The play raises questions about the nature of love, loyalty, and whether it can be a force for good or a source of moral failings.

   Proteus speaks to the complexity of love and betrayal in Act 2, Scene 6:

   “Love is a smoke made with the fume of sighs; Being purged, a fire sparkling in lovers’ eyes; Being vexed, a sea nourished with lovers’ tears: What is it else? A madness most discreet, A choking gall and a preserving sweet.”

   In this famous passage, Proteus acknowledges the contradictions of love—its ability to inspire both happiness and pain. His confusion is symbolic of the tumultuous emotional journey that many of the characters experience throughout the play.

3. Identity and Disguise: Disguise and mistaken identity play a major role in The Two Gentlemen of Verona. Julia disguises herself as a boy to follow Proteus to Milan, and later, when Valentine and Proteus are both in pursuit of Silvia, the confusion over who is who leads to further misunderstandings and complications. This theme ties into the broader Shakespearean motif of transformation and self-discovery through disguise. In a sense, the characters’ use of disguises is a means for them to test their identities and challenge the societal expectations placed upon them.

   One of the most striking examples of this is when Julia, disguised as “Sebastian,” is able to witness the effects of her lover Proteus’ betrayal firsthand. Julia’s internal struggle with her identity is voiced when she says:

   “It is a strange disguise. How far beyond the bounds of modesty we would be, to disfigure ourselves in the name of love?” (Act 2, Scene 7)

   This line reflects Julia’s internal conflict and the tension between her desire for Proteus and her pride as a woman scorned.

4. Self-Discovery and Growth: One of the play’s key messages is that personal growth and self-discovery are essential components of the human experience. By the end of the play, both Proteus and Valentine have learned valuable lessons about loyalty, love, and friendship. Proteus’ eventual realization of the importance of his friendship with Valentine, and his repentance for betraying him, serves as the play’s moral lesson. The final resolution, in which Proteus is forgiven and his relationship with Valentine is restored, underscores the possibility of redemption and the value of personal transformation.

   This theme is emphasized in Valentine’s reflection on loyalty and friendship in Act 5, Scene 4:

   “I do forgive thee, as I would be forgiven. I do repent for you, and will love you forever.”

   These lines mark the moment when Proteus is finally accepted back into the fold, and the idea of forgiveness as a transformative act takes center stage.

5. Fate and the Role of Chance: The play also explores how fate and chance play a significant role in shaping events. The characters’ fortunes often change unpredictably, and the resolution of the play relies on a series of fortunate coincidences. This element of chance gives the play a somewhat whimsical feel, as it hinges on the idea that fate often works in mysterious ways. The positive resolution of the play suggests that sometimes, the unpredictable nature of life can lead to happiness and reconciliation.

   In Act 5, Scene 4, Valentine remarks:

   “To thank me, I am the one who’s granted this! Fortune has given us this moment.”

   Here, Valentine expresses his belief that their happy ending is the result of a happy turn of fate, reinforcing the theme of life’s uncertainty and the role of luck in shaping the outcomes of their lives.

The Characters

1. Valentine: Valentine is the more virtuous of the two gentlemen. He is sincere, loyal, and brave in his pursuit of love. His character represents the ideal of friendship and love, although he too must learn how to navigate betrayal and disappointment. He is the one who consistently values friendship above love, and his ability to forgive Proteus represents the play’s message of redemption and growth.

2. Proteus: Proteus is the more complex and conflicted character. Initially, he is deeply in love with Julia, but his affections shift when he meets Silvia. His betrayal of Valentine marks a central turning point in the play, and his eventual remorse and repentance provide the play with its moral core. Proteus’ journey is one of self-discovery, and his character arc revolves around the tension between love and loyalty.

3. Julia: Julia is Proteus’ steadfast lover, whose loyalty is unwavering despite his betrayal. Her decision to disguise herself as a boy and follow Proteus to Milan is both an act of love and self-respect. Julia’s strength and intelligence shine through her actions, and by the end of the play, she is rewarded for her loyalty and perseverance.

4. Silvia: Silvia is the object of both Valentine and Proteus’ affections. Although she is a passive character in many respects, she serves as a catalyst for much of the conflict in the play. Silvia is portrayed as intelligent and independent, and her love for Valentine is unwavering, even as Proteus attempts to woo her.

5. Launce and Speed: Launce, the clownish servant of Proteus, and Speed, Valentine’s witty servant, provide comic relief throughout the play. Their banter and misunderstandings lighten the tone and offer a humorous contrast to the more serious elements of the plot.

Famous Lines and Their Significance

1. “I am too young to know what I am, and I am too old to care.” (Act 2, Scene 1)

   This line, spoken by Speed, humorously comments on the complex and contradictory nature of youth and age. It reflects the play’s theme of self-discovery and the inner conflict that the characters experience as they navigate the complexities of love and friendship.

2. “All is fair in love and war.” (Act 1, Scene 1)

   This famous line, spoken by Valentine, encapsulates the play’s exploration of the ways in which love can lead to questionable moral choices. It reflects the idea that the pursuit of love can justify actions that might otherwise be seen as wrong or deceitful.

3. “I’ll love you to my life’s end. I’ll see you gone before I reach your house.” (Act 5, Scene 4)

   This line, spoken by Proteus, signals his eventual repentance and his realization of the value of loyalty and friendship over love. It marks his return to the fold and the reconciliation between him and Valentine.

Conclusion

The Two Gentlemen of Verona is a delightful yet thought-provoking comedy that explores the complexities of friendship, love, betrayal, and personal growth. The play’s witty dialogue, charming characters, and engaging plot continue to captivate audiences, making it a valuable entry in Shakespeare’s canon. Through its exploration of loyalty, self-discovery, and forgiveness, The Two Gentlemen of Verona offers timeless lessons on the intricacies of human relationships and the transformative power of love.

Despite its early composition, The Two Gentlemen of Verona remains a testament to Shakespeare’s genius in capturing the nuances of the human experience. The characters’ growth and the play’s resolution offer a sense of hope, showing that even in the face of betrayal, forgiveness and redemption are possible.

Acting Magazine Newsletters

Never miss out on the best from Acting Magazine.

Sign me up for the newsletter!